Step 5: Test the System with a Small Team

Once you’ve taken the time to define your church’s unique needs (Step 1), it’s time to prioritize which features matter most in a Church Management System (CMS). With so many systems on the market, each boasting a long list of features, it’s easy to get dazzled by flashy extras that sound impressive but may not actually serve your church well.

The key is to focus on what will genuinely help your church better know, love, and care for your people. This step will help you cut through the noise and evaluate systems with clarity.

Separate Must-Have Features from Nice-to-Have Features

Start by identifying which features are non-negotiable for your church. These are the functions without which the system would be practically useless. Then, distinguish the nice-to-have features that would add value but aren’t critical.

Here are some common must-have features for most churches:

• Membership Management - Tracking member information, attendance, and engagement.‍
• Communication Tools - Built-in email, text messaging, and push notifications to specific groups.‍
• Online Giving Integration - Seamless online giving, including recurring donations and financial reporting.‍
• Event Management - Tools to create events, manage registrations, and track attendance.‍
• Volunteer Scheduling - Coordinating volunteers across various ministries and services.

Meanwhile, nice-to-have features might include:

• Customizable dashboards
• Check-in systems for kids and volunteers
• Mobile apps for members
• Advanced reporting with data visualization

By categorizing features this way, you ensure you’re focusing on what matters most and not getting sidetracked by extras that sound cool but may not bring real value to your ministry.

Weigh Short-Term Needs Against Long-Term Goals

It’s easy to prioritize features based solely on current needs, but remember that a CMS is a long-term investment. You want a system that can grow with your church, not one that will need to be replaced in a few years.

Ask yourself:

• Will this system still meet our needs if our membership doubles?
• Can it support new ministries or programs we might launch in the future?
• Does it offer integrations with other tools we may adopt down the road?

Prioritizing both short-term and long-term needs ensures that you choose a system that won’t just solve today’s problems but will also serve you well in the future.

Consider Ease of Use

A feature is only valuable if your staff and volunteers can actually use it. Even the most powerful CMS can be rendered ineffective if it’s too complex to navigate.

When evaluating ease of use, consider:

• User-friendliness: Is the interface intuitive for non-technical staff?
• Training resources: Does the vendor offer clear documentation, tutorials, or live support?
• Adoption time: How long will it take for your team to feel comfortable using the system?

Choosing a system that balances robust functionality with ease of use will lead to greater adoption and long-term success.

Involve Key Stakeholders

Remember, prioritizing features isn’t a solo task. Involve key stakeholders who will use the system regularly. This includes:

• Ministry Leaders: They can highlight specific needs for their teams.
• Administrative Staff: They often handle the day-to-day tasks and can identify which features will save the most time.
• IT Team: If you have one, they can assess the technical side, such as integrations and data security.

Gathering input from various perspectives ensures that no critical needs are overlooked.

Create a Scoring System

To objectively prioritize features, you can use a simple scoring system:

1. List all potential features.
2. Assign a score from 1 to 5 based on how critical each feature is (5 being essential, 1 being optional).
3. Add up the scores to determine the overall importance of each feature.

This method helps remove bias and keeps the prioritization process focused on what truly matters.

Conclusion

Prioritizing features based on your church’s needs is a vital step in choosing the right CMS. By distinguishing must-haves from nice-to-haves, weighing short-term needs against long-term goals, and involving key stakeholders, you can ensure that the system you choose will genuinely serve your ministry.

In the next post, we’ll move on to Step 3: Research and Shortlist Potential Systems, where we’ll guide you on how to efficiently research different CMS options and narrow down your choices.

Need help prioritizing features for your church? I’m here to walk alongside you in this process. Let’s build something better together. Schedule a consultation today!

‍